Join the discussion.

Inklings News

Join the discussion.

Inklings News

Join the discussion.

Inklings News

Why I Choose to be a Socialist

Graphic+by+Owen+Karrel+10+
Graphic by Owen Karrel ’10

Constance Chien ’10
Features Editor

Graphic by Owen Karrel '10
Graphic by Owen Karrel '10

When I tell people I’m a socialist, they give one of three reactions: they shrug and say “cool;” they give me a strange look and attack me for my beliefs (this can be not fun); or maybe they smile in reconciliation with another fellow Marxist.

I, for one, believe that socialism has value in today’s society, despite the leftover bad feelings for the movement from the McCarthy era.

I say this because what socialism means is that we become a community and that we support a government that will, in turn, protect and sustain us by either controlling labor or allowing the workers to control labor.

In doing so, we prevent certain failures of capitalism, namely the potential to exploit the people through corporate greed and monopolizing.

In theory, socialism isn’t all that bad.

There are already many socialistic elements of our society that are well appreciated. Public schools, anyone? And highways? These elements are not called socialism explicitly (if they were, I imagine crowds would protest their additions out of fear of that word), but they are very much so socialistically controlled.

The socialism that is often associated with books like “1984” or “Animal Farm” isn’t really the whole picture. In fact, the situation in “1984” (a book by George Orwell in which an authoritarian government controls every aspect of citizens’ existences) could indeed happen with an economic system based on capitalism.

The potential for an authoritarian government isn’t limited to when governments have socialism as an economic system – not at all.

The potential for unmerited and unwelcome control of the brainwashing sort exists in pretty much every form of government, no matter which economic system the government may follow.

In fact, I may argue that the American politics in the 1950s is a good example of how government can take control of its people.

Ironically enough, this period was a time when the government tried to get rid of any trace of socialism and communism in American society.

And yet, government in this period took on authoritarian characteristics. It took on an aura of suspicion. It tried and jailed people unfairly for having certain associations or beliefs, or for having sympathies with the political Left. In other words, it became what we now associate with the faults of socialism.

Furthermore, capitalism is a system built on greed. Seriously.

The reason why people say that capitalism works is because it encourages competition because people want the best for themselves out of a “natural” human tendency.

Capitalism reduces us, therefore, to cultural clichés.

We don’t have to be greedy. Human nature isn’t universal and immutable, and even if one is of the belief that it is, I believe that being nice to one another is a fundamental quality of being human.

We can and truly could become supportive of each other if we all decided to. Socialism doesn’t have to go against antiquated, cynical notions of human nature.

Franklin Delano Roosevelt (to whom I, as well as many Americans. affectionately refer as “FDR”) faced the same opposition regarding his New Deal plan that that the Democratic Party currently draws for its “socialistic” views on health care. FDR is essentially the reason we got through the Great Depression.

With the recent economic crisis, perhaps we should reconsider the capitalist morality of unrestrained, unwise economic growth and greed. Perhaps we should trust one another and pull through with socialism.

Socialism implies a system in which we help each other and everyone is treated with due fairness, so why is “socialism” a word with such negative connotation?

I’d rather be economically governed by a well-informed government that closely regulates and supports me rather than by the cold trappings of an economic system with only one rule: be greedy, and look out for only yourself.

View Comments (5)
More to Discover

Comments (5)

All Inklings News Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • C

    CapiTALismworksMay 27, 2010 at 10:49 pm

    yes i spelt capitalism wrong

    Reply
  • C

    CapilitismworksMay 27, 2010 at 10:48 pm

    Note that FDR prolonged the Great Depression with his various government policies. It was only WWII that brought us out of the Great Depression. More importantly, socialism is unsustainable, and does “fairness” mean that the government can take someone else’s money that they earned themselves and give it to others through welfare while they sit on their butts doing nothing? I hope not. As the saying goes, “The problem with socialism is that sooner or later you run out of other people’s money”. Greed isn’t what capitalism is based ob, it’s self-interest. Without self-interest, there is no motivation to work hard or innovate. Capitalism, though not perfect, is the most sustainable economic system that has brought the most people out of poverty and advanced human society the greatest. period.

    Reply
  • I

    Inklings ReaderNov 3, 2009 at 4:01 am

    Interesting point of view. However, it should probably be noted that the quality of public school education differs depending on where it is, so it is not truly equal, or socialist…more an attempt to reform capitalism and make things more fair.

    Also, capitalism is not based on greed. It is based on the principle that if you work hard, you can have a better life…this concept of hard work is one that is ignored by socialism, and it has been proven that socialist nations struggle greatly with providing for their people while also upholding the common principals of human rights.

    Finally, socialism goes against many of the ideas and freedoms set forth in our Constitution, so I'm afraid our nation will never adopt these ideas. But thanks for the article!

    Reply
  • I

    Isaac SteinOct 19, 2009 at 3:30 pm

    Our textbooks glorify FDR… but do remember that he did some shady things like try to add justices to the Supreme Court in order to further his policies (stacking the court)… and the economy was struggling up until WWII broke out, so it it fair to attribute New Deal policies as the sole cause of our economic recovery? Also, what’s wrong with a system based on greed? I honestly can’t think of a motivator that’s more effective in real life. But I agree that so called “anti-communists” like McCarthy were probably just jerks trying to manipulate the fears of Americans en masse for their own gain.

    Reply
    • A

      an Inklings readerOct 25, 2009 at 8:16 pm

      A few choice quotations from the Tao te Ching:

      When there is no desire,
      all things are at peace.

      If you overvalue possessions,
      people begin to steal.

      Fill your bowl to the brim
      and it will spill.
      Keep sharpening your knife
      and it will blunt.
      Chase after money and security
      and your heart will never unclench.

      The world is sacred.
      It can’t be improved.
      If you tamper with it, you’ll ruin it.
      If you treat it like an object, you’ll lose it.

      Reply