The Chevrolet Volt: An Electric Solution?
April 27, 2011 • 2,151 views
There seems to be no escaping the fact that the price of gas is rising. It’s on the news, it’s in the papers and it’s one of the most common conversations among those who are paying for fuel. Many adults might reminisce about 1970 when a gallon of gas cost 36 cents, but those days are gone forever. Now it’s 2011, gas is surpassing four dollars a gallon in Connecticut, and many new drivers are looking for a solution to this costly problem.
Though the rising gas prices have been all over the media, the actual cause for this increase may be more complicated then it initially seems.
“When people think of rising crude oil and gasoline prices, the turmoil in the Middle East and the Deepwater Horizon disaster quickly spring to mind. However those are not the only two big drivers behind the increase in oil prices,” said Mark Schwabacher ’13, a co-president of the Staples debate team and member of Student Assembly who is knowledgeable about politics and current events.
Schwabacher explained that events like these have little actual impact, as they affect only a small portion of the massive oil supply system.
“One of the main causes of the sustained increase in oil prices in the last year is increased demand by developing nations such as China and India. Just this year, China surpassed America as the world’s largest energy consumer,” Schwabacher said.
Kristin Forbes, a professor at MIT and former member of the White House’s Council of Economic Advisers, also sees increasing foreign oil use as a cause of rising gas prices.
“Oil is priced in dollars on the world market. When the dollar is weaker, foreign currencies are stronger, by definition. That means people in other countries can buy more oil for the same amount of money… As people in other countries buy more, demand rises, and it drives up the price in dollars,” Forbes said in an interview.
Regardless of the cause for the rise in gas prices, students at Staples are certainly feeling the effect.
“My car used to take about $25 to fill, now it takes at least $35. The price increase means that more of my paycheck goes to gas, which is a bummer,” said Andrea Stefenson ’11, driver of a 2004 Honda Civic.
Many Staples students are looking for a solution to this gas problem in more fuel-efficient cars.
“If I had the option to get a new car, I would definitely choose to get a hybrid. They are usually a greater investment up front, but with gas prices on the rise and peak oil upon us, I think it would be better in the long run,” said Diana Somlo ’11, who currently drives a GMC Yukon XL.
However, hybrids have been on the market since the late ‘90s. What’s new are electric vehicles, which is why I took a test drive in the new Chevrolet Volt to see if this car is the answer to Staples students’ fuel problems.
First let me explain what makes the Volt unique. This car is called an extended range electric vehicle. According to Chevrolet, this means it can run for about 35 miles solely on an electric charge, after which the gas generator kicks in, giving the car a total range of 375 miles for one tank of gas and a full charge.
Right off the bat this sounds like the most practical electric vehicle. The Volt could be used like a normal car, as compared with a full electric vehicle like the Nissan Leaf that provides an electric range of about 100 miles, after which you are done, and it’s time to call a tow truck.
So the Volt seems like the best of both worlds, it produces zero emissions when electric, but its gas engine will prevent from ever being stranded.
At the dealership I saw the car for the first time. It’s not a bad looking automobile. The flat integrated rear taillights, filled-in grille section and stylized headlights give the car a futuristic look that fits its abilities. However, the overall shape of the car might turn off some potential buyers. The Volt essentially has similar proportions to the Prius due to a hood that is almost at the same angle as the windshield, and the rear that drops off flat after only a small slope from the roofline. Though this shape makes the Volt aerodynamic and therefore fuel efficient, it reduces the car’s ability to look sporty or aggressive.
On the inside of the car the traditional dashboard has been replaced with an LCD screen. When the car is running, this screen shows an abundance of information: battery range, gas range, combined range, driving efficiency and speed, just to name a few. While this display might baffle someone is technologically challenged, the average Staples student should feel right at home in the driver’s seat.
However, the rest of the interior is not nearly as impressive. The quantity of dark plastic on the doors and dashboard, as well as the cheap-feeling leather seats (“premium cloth” was actually the standard trim) were far from luxurious or exciting.
The salesman compared the ride noise of the car to a golf cart, an accurate description. Besides a bit of electrical whine, there is no noise from the engine, though the sound from the tires and outside air does seem louder as a result.
Since I don’t yet have a driver’s license, I couldn’t actually get behind the wheel of the vehicle. However, my dad, who did test it, said that the car felt adequately powered and that the steering and braking were both comparable to an ordinary gas-powered car.
Though the charging time of 10 hours may seem high to some people, this problem can be solved with the instillation of a 240-volt charging system. It can fully power the car in as little as four hours, which equates to the meager hours of sleep many Staples students get.
However, there is one looming problem with the Volt: price. The car’s MSRP is $41,000. It is eligible for up to $7,500 in tax credit from the government, but that is still $33,500, which is far from cheap.
Regardless of any savings, at $40,000, the Volt should be competitive with similarly priced cars like the BMW 3 series or Audi A4 that are also in the $35,000 to $40,000 range, and the quality of the Volt simply can’t compare with those vehicles. If you purchase the Volt you are really paying for the new technology, not a car that is worth that price overall.
“I’d like to consider a more energy efficient vehicle. The Chevy Volt sounds cool, but I think it is out of my price range,” said A.P Environmental teacher Michael Aitkenhead.
For less then half of the price of a Volt, a Staples student could buy a used car that is still energy efficient, like a Prius or Civic. Aitkenhead, who teaches A.P. Environmental Science, said that a student can then minimize his gas usage by simply keeping tires inflated, carrying only essentials in the car and sticking to low speeds and slow acceleration.
In the end the Volt is a good car and probably the most sensible electric vehicle on the market. However, it’s still a huge oxymoron: it’s an expensive way to save money on fuel.